New Undergraduate Thesis on Seasteading Law & Policy
June 19, 2013 by chdeist
The following blog post was written by Adrian Petrilli, who recently completed his undergraduate thesis on seasteading legal strategy at The American University of Rome. You can view the extended abstract here, and the entire research paper in PDF format here. The opinions expressed are not expressly those of The Seasteading Insitute, but we value Petrilli’s perspective and contribution and welcome the paper’s positive findings regarding the feasibility of seasteading in the current paradigm.
In today’s world, can a fully sovereign seastead exist? Considering the current legal system and political atmosphere, two questions have to be asked: is it legal, and is it politically plausible? With the Earth almost entirely portioned out to existing nation states or declared res communis via robust international treaties, the most substantial world commons left are the high seas. This, as can be noted, has created a tempting location and scenario for habitation and experimentation with new political systems via floating communities commonly referred to as seasteads. The connected paper takes a look at what current legal and political issues seasteads are likely to encounter when dealing with traditional land based states in their bid to become a country themselves.
Democracy In Dinghies: Fiefdoms By Flotilla: The Proliferation of Political Entities via Seasteads argues that a seastead can exist within today’s legal framework without relying on future evolutions or changes to international law. However, in order for a seastead to gain sovereignty, it would need a creative solution to achieve recognition and join the cliquish international community of states.
The paper analyzes the current international legal and political environment while outlining the possibilities (and hardships) a seastead would face in its quest to become an autonomous ocean community. Some will point out an obvious difficulty with this research as seasteads are only a theoretical endeavor at the moment and therefore there is no concrete example to analyze. However, case studies of artificial island country projects do exist, such as The Republic of Minerva and the well-known Principality of Sealand, among others. These experiments are interesting because of the number of similarities they share with a seasteading project, such as the motivation to gain sovereignty and challenges that come with it, i.e., maritime law compliance, and so on. Of course, seasteading poses distinct challenges to current maritime law and potentially has the capacity to change the international custom of what constitutes a state. For instance, all States currently exist on terra firma (land), not artificial platforms, islands, or vessels; seasteads would thus be the first to buck the trend.
Seasteads and their ability to gain sovereignty is a relevant topic for a number of reasons, most of which are well outlined by the Seasteading Institute. Among these, there is the fact that technological advancement has made previously un-settleable areas feasible. Furthermore, a lack of any area on Earth that can be used to form a new country without infringing on another’s sovereignty also makes the high seas more attractive for such an experiment. Even now, the high seas are being used to find creative solutions to complex problems, such as the Dutch charity Women on Waves, which performs medical procedures (not allowed in the coastal state) for women past the 12-mile exclusion zone.
Democracy In Dinghies: Fiefdoms By Flotilla delves into international law and takes into account the large number of regulations, the regime governing the oceans, norms of political practice regarding the creation of new states, and general societal custom regarding free passage. By analyzing legal documents and case studies of micronation projects (i.e., the Principality of Sealand), customs of global policy pertaining to non-traditional entities’ attempts to gain sovereignty will be made clear.
I look forward to this community’s feedback, suggestions and comments.